Soft, moist, and packed with rich banana flavour, this classic banana cake is a Kiwi favourite. Perfectly sweet with a tender crumb, it’s even better topped with velvety chocolate or lemon icing. A simple, no-fail bake that’s ideal for afternoon tea, birthdays, or any time you crave a comforting slice of homemade goodness.
{has_more=true, offset=160, total=168, results=[{comment_text=This would have to be the best Banana Cake I have made......and I have made a few in my time. It is tasty and very moist. I needed to extend the cooking time to 65min, approved=true, user_name=Karla, hs_createdate=1702249854471, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175565974}, {comment_text=I made this today with my son. it's very nice and simple, approved=true, user_name=very nice banana cake, hs_createdate=1702249854414, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175392335}, {comment_text=I made this twice last week as we loved the first one and we had alot of bananas going black. Made two double mixtures and both were absolutely perfect and moist!! The next one I make I'm going to try a different flavoured yoghurt. Also the second time around, I added more lemon to the icing as it only calls for two tbsp, I think I added the juice of two whole small lemons and didnt taste it before I iced the cake and the extra tang balanced out the sweetness. It was devine! I think the reviewers that said it's the worst recipe made it wrong.lol. this recipe is being stored in my personal recipe book. Thanks to whoever shared this :), approved=true, user_name=Shae, hs_createdate=1702249854378, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175501361}, {comment_text=Awful. The others are right it didn't cook properly in the time stated. cooked it an extra 30 minutes but it still wasn't quite right.CHELSEA: Hi there, we have re-tested the recipe this week and have slightly increased the cooking temp (from 160°C to 170°C) and time (from 45-50 min to 50-60 min). While our one still tasted yummy at the lower temperature, we agree that it was taking longer to cook. Ovens can vary so much, so it definitely pays to keep an eye on the cake while it is cooking., approved=true, user_name=sally Fahey, hs_createdate=1702249854081, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175405172}, {comment_text=I have made this cake twice and it works well I use a cake tin with a hole in the centre so don't get uncooked centre works well takes 60 minutes to cook I'll check at 50 min cant reccomend this recipe enough thank you, approved=true, user_name=1572035637, hs_createdate=1702249853753, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175374652}, {comment_text=Have always made banana cakes and decided to try this one a few weeks ago, now I make it weekly and its very popular with all of us and the neighbors. I first tried it with the apricot flavoured yogurt and then with other fruit yogurts they all work out beautifully. Thank you for this recipe. It is my favourite now and the bonus of the lemon icing which has always been my favourite icing to have on a banana cake., approved=true, user_name=Carol Ann, hs_createdate=1702249853327, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175361079}, {comment_text=I decided to bake at 3am as you do.. turned out almost perfect. Forgot to put the sugar. Dammit., approved=true, user_name=Joy, hs_createdate=1702249852566, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175400570}, {comment_text=Absolutely scrumptious especially with the lemon icing and the yoghurt makes cake so moist!!!, approved=true, user_name=christine stanley-hunt, hs_createdate=1702249851972, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175451753}, {comment_text=Beautiful banana cake recipe. Loved by my family., approved=true, user_name=Shaz, hs_createdate=1702249851616, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175374634}, {comment_text=my cake didn't cook properly even though i did everything the recipe told me to do :(, approved=true, user_name=sasha, hs_createdate=1702249851613, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175446911}]}
Reviews
168
What did you think of this recipe?
Karla
This would have to be the best Banana Cake I have made......and I have made a few in my time. It is tasty and very moist. I needed to extend the cooking time to 65min
5
very nice banana cake
I made this today with my son. it's very nice and simple
5
Shae
I made this twice last week as we loved the first one and we had alot of bananas going black. Made two double mixtures and both were absolutely perfect and moist!! The next one I make I'm going to try a different flavoured yoghurt. Also the second time around, I added more lemon to the icing as it only calls for two tbsp, I think I added the juice of two whole small lemons and didnt taste it before I iced the cake and the extra tang balanced out the sweetness. It was devine! I think the reviewers that said it's the worst recipe made it wrong.lol. this recipe is being stored in my personal recipe book. Thanks to whoever shared this :)
5
sally Fahey
Awful. The others are right it didn't cook properly in the time stated. cooked it an extra 30 minutes but it still wasn't quite right.CHELSEA: Hi there, we have re-tested the recipe this week and have slightly increased the cooking temp (from 160°C to 170°C) and time (from 45-50 min to 50-60 min). While our one still tasted yummy at the lower temperature, we agree that it was taking longer to cook. Ovens can vary so much, so it definitely pays to keep an eye on the cake while it is cooking.
1
1572035637
I have made this cake twice and it works well I use a cake tin with a hole in the centre so don't get uncooked centre works well takes 60 minutes to cook I'll check at 50 min cant reccomend this recipe enough thank you
5
Carol Ann
Have always made banana cakes and decided to try this one a few weeks ago, now I make it weekly and its very popular with all of us and the neighbors. I first tried it with the apricot flavoured yogurt and then with other fruit yogurts they all work out beautifully. Thank you for this recipe. It is my favourite now and the bonus of the lemon icing which has always been my favourite icing to have on a banana cake.
5
Joy
I decided to bake at 3am as you do.. turned out almost perfect. Forgot to put the sugar. Dammit.
5
christine stanley-hunt
Absolutely scrumptious especially with the lemon icing and the yoghurt makes cake so moist!!!
5
Shaz
Beautiful banana cake recipe. Loved by my family.
5
sasha
my cake didn't cook properly even though i did everything the recipe told me to do :(
Preheat oven to 170°C conventional / 150ºC fan-forced. Grease a 21cm round springform or regular cake tin (with high sides) and line the base with baking paper.
Beat Chelsea White Sugar (or Chelsea Organic Raw Sugar), melted Butter and eggs until pale and creamy. Add the mashed ripe bananas and beat well.
Heat Meadow Fresh Original Milk in the microwave until nearly boiling (approximately 1 minute). Mix in Edmonds Baking Soda, then stir into the banana mixture.
Add the Meadow Fresh Yoghurt, Edmonds Standard Grade Flour and Edmonds Baking Powder. Mix well and pour into the prepared cake tin.
Add the Meadow Fresh Yoghurt, Edmonds Standard Grade Flour and Edmonds Baking Powder. Mix well and pour into the prepared cake tin.
Bake for 50-60 minutes, until cake is cooked in the middle and just pulling away from the edges of the tin (insert a skewer into the centre - if it comes out clean the cake is cooked). Cool in tin for 5 minutes then release the sides and cool on a wire rack. When cold, swirl with icing.
Lemon Icing In a bowl, mix the Chelsea Icing Sugar and lemon juice. AddTararua Butter and beat until light and fluffy. Add a little hot water for a softer consistency if required.
Frequently asked questions
How can I ensure my banana cake turns out moist?
To achieve a moist banana cake, use overripe bananas as they add natural sweetness and moisture. Incorporating ingredients like yoghurt or sour cream can further enhance the cake's tenderness.
Can I substitute oil for butter in my banana cake recipe?
Yes, you can replace butter with an equal amount of oil to achieve a moist texture. However, note that this substitution may slightly alter the cake's flavor profile.
Can I freeze banana cake for later use?
Absolutely! Once cooled, wrap the cake tightly in plastic wrap and then in an airtight container. Store in the freezer for up to three months. Thaw at room temperature before serving. It's also best to make your icing fresh, as it doesn't freeze well.
This would have to be the best Banana Cake I have made......and I have made a few in my time. It is tasty and very moist. I needed to extend the cooking time to 65min
5
very nice banana cake
I made this today with my son. it's very nice and simple
5
Shae
I made this twice last week as we loved the first one and we had alot of bananas going black. Made two double mixtures and both were absolutely perfect and moist!! The next one I make I'm going to try a different flavoured yoghurt. Also the second time around, I added more lemon to the icing as it only calls for two tbsp, I think I added the juice of two whole small lemons and didnt taste it before I iced the cake and the extra tang balanced out the sweetness. It was devine! I think the reviewers that said it's the worst recipe made it wrong.lol. this recipe is being stored in my personal recipe book. Thanks to whoever shared this :)
5
sally Fahey
Awful. The others are right it didn't cook properly in the time stated. cooked it an extra 30 minutes but it still wasn't quite right.CHELSEA: Hi there, we have re-tested the recipe this week and have slightly increased the cooking temp (from 160°C to 170°C) and time (from 45-50 min to 50-60 min). While our one still tasted yummy at the lower temperature, we agree that it was taking longer to cook. Ovens can vary so much, so it definitely pays to keep an eye on the cake while it is cooking.
1
1572035637
I have made this cake twice and it works well I use a cake tin with a hole in the centre so don't get uncooked centre works well takes 60 minutes to cook I'll check at 50 min cant reccomend this recipe enough thank you
5
Carol Ann
Have always made banana cakes and decided to try this one a few weeks ago, now I make it weekly and its very popular with all of us and the neighbors. I first tried it with the apricot flavoured yogurt and then with other fruit yogurts they all work out beautifully. Thank you for this recipe. It is my favourite now and the bonus of the lemon icing which has always been my favourite icing to have on a banana cake.
5
Joy
I decided to bake at 3am as you do.. turned out almost perfect. Forgot to put the sugar. Dammit.
5
christine stanley-hunt
Absolutely scrumptious especially with the lemon icing and the yoghurt makes cake so moist!!!
5
Shaz
Beautiful banana cake recipe. Loved by my family.
5
sasha
my cake didn't cook properly even though i did everything the recipe told me to do :(